Sunday, April 28, 2013

"Don't judge me because of my pooka!"


The film Harvey is a lovely film about a supposed “imaginary” six foot, three and a half inches tall white rabbit named Harvey.  I am not sure what Harvey in particular represents but I have a couple ideas what he could symbolize.  I am almost positive that the filmmaker did not intend to prove the existence of a big white invisible rabbit known as a pooka.  However, the filmmaker might have used Harvey as a symbol for unconventional ideas, according to the society of that time, that shape individual’s lives and actions.  Even though the results of that belief are beautiful, people still judge them as bad because of the belief behind them.  Another idea is that perhaps Harvey represents God.  Since God is invisible and reveals Himself only to those who choose believe in Him or who allow themselves to acknowledge Him, this symbol makes sense to me but not, however, according to the time period that the play and movie was made.  In any case, whatever or whoever Harvey represents, Elwood P. Dowd is falsely judged and poorly treated because of his believe in the existence of the pooka. 
However, ‘whether Harvey exists or not’ is not the question that the movie really addresses, but rather ‘is it worth taking away one’s joy when proving the nonexistence of Harvey or whatever he represents’.  With Harvey, Elwood is the sweetest, most non-judgmental, most gallant, and gentlemanly character in the entire movie.  He makes friends with misjudged drunkards, criminals, and almost everyone he comes into contact with.   Veta Simmons, Elwood’s sister, realizes that if she stifles her brother’s belief and relationship with Harvey, she would, in turn, put out his fire, or his joy and purpose in life, as it were.  The filmmakers show the audience that obliterating someone’s beliefs for the sake of proving them wrong is, one, not always loving and, two, not always helpful but rather it is usually harmful.

4 comments:

  1. I was also unsure about what Harvey represented, these are good theories though!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like what you point out about Elwood's sister. She finally realized that it was not important to figure out whether pooka was real or not, but rather preserve the good quality person she had as a brother.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like the idea that Harvey could be God. After all, Elwood listens to him about everything, like many people do with God.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I really like what you have said about the importance of allowing other people to have their beliefs. I feel however, that it was important to prove Harvey's existence because that is partially how the movie makes its points about reality and existence. If Harvey did not exist, or if his existence was ambiguous it would not really matter that Veta and others are trying to disprove his existence (at least where the question of reality is involved).

    ReplyDelete