We Are Afraid of Thinking as Individuals
I appreciate what Life of Brian
says about religion. I think that organized religions often use
their central figures rather than follow them.
It seems that people hear what they want to hear, follow the
teachings they like, and use religious teachings to justify their
actions. The film suggests that Jesus (aka Brian) did not want to be
followed, and that those who claimed to follow him actually twisted
his words, misinterpreted his statements, and forced him to be the
prophet they wanted rather than the man he was. The only thing Brian
really says is that people are individuals and should follow their
own thoughts and develop their own values, but this point is totally
ignored. Perhaps, it is easier to follow than to innovate.
Historically,
it is clear that all religions are based on interpretation, but the
film plays with the idea that Christianity was fabricated by humans
for their own desires, that Jesus was just a pawn used by some for
political reasons and by others to give direction when they did not
want to think for themselves. In my own experience I see seen the
manipulation of the Bible in a similar way. Though the Bible
describes the earth as the creation of God, christians all over the
world continue to destroy it and claim they are devoted to God.
In
the end, the film really looks at human nature. It shows people
hearing what they want to hear, doing what they want to do, and
believing what they want to believe. Pontius Pilate never wakes up
to the fact that everyone laughing at him. The People's Front of
Judea can't get anything done because they spend all of their time
either fighting with other movements or discussing policies. They
don't listen when someone tries to convince them to actually do
something. Brain's followers don't really listen to what he is
saying,. In the end even Judith and his mother remain stuck in their
own views of Brian and what is happening to him. Basically, those
with an agenda see everything through the lens of that agenda, and
those like Brian who just want peace and quiet get caught in the
middle of the problems.
The
film makes all of these points through humor. If a drama or a
documentary was making the same point, many people would not listen
or would feel offended. The film is able to criticize and mock
religion and human nature without being too offensive because it
incorporates silliness and humor that everyone can relate to. A lot
of us know what it is like to be nagged by our mother, or to be told
in an annoying way to look on the bright side. We can all laugh at a
crazy naked man running around, or an oblivious leader with a speech
impediment saying “Biggus Dickus.” Humor helps us deal with
difficult topics in a way that feels safe. It changes anger,
frustration, and cynicism into something positive. Monty Python's
use of humor allows us to look at ourselves and the world, see the
problems and faults, and laugh at it all.
I didn't feel this movie was offensive either, but religious fanatics probably didn't feel the same way.
ReplyDelete"Basically, those with an agenda see everything through the lens of that agenda, and those like Brian who just want peace and quiet get caught in the middle of the problems."
ReplyDeleteThat's a wonderful take-away.